Comparing conventional and computer-assisted surgery baseplate and screw placement in reverse shoulder arthroplasty.
These authors used a custom-designed system allowing computed tomography-based preoperative planning, intraoperative navigation, and postoperative evaluation. Each of five surgeon performed 3 computer-assisted and 3 conventional simulated procedures on 3-dimensional CT reconstructed cadaveric shoulders. The 3-dimensional CT reconstructed postoperative units were digitally matched to a preoperative model for evaluation of entry points, end points, and angulations of screws and baseplate.
They found no difference in accuracy or precision of screws or baseplate entry points. Accuracy and precision were improved with the use of navigation for end points and angulations of 3 of the four screws. Navigated baseplate end point precision (but not the accuracy) was significantly improved.
These results relate to a specific baseplate system. Other designs have parallel screws, so screw angulation is not an issue. Screw length is usually not an issue unless it is excessive.
In our practice we rarely obtain CT scans before reverse total shoulder arthroplasty except in cases of severe deformity or bone loss. This research did not include such pathoanatomy.
From this paper we do not know the additional cost or time necessary for the CT scans, the preoperative planning, or the making of the navigation tools. From the information presented it is not possible to determine the value (benefit/cost) of such a system or its utility in actual surgery.
To see the topics covered in this Blog, click here
Use the "Search" box to the right to find other topics of interest to you.