Coffee at the Rendezvous Hut, January 8, 2020.
I was invited to present a few thoughts about LIFE to the ASES Fellows Course in Chicago.
For those unable to attend I share it here.
Life
Setting directions, not goals
Our lives as people who do surgery, and how to make them the most satisfying they can be.
I have been asked to talk to you a bit about life. Our lives — not as surgeons, but as people who do surgery. The question is how we can lead the most satisfying lives.
Lots of folks like to set goals. But while achieving a goal can be satisfying, the satisfaction often fades quickly. If we achieve a goal, we start worrying about setting the next one. If we don’t achieve the goal, we feel like a failure.
In contrast to setting goals, I find that setting directions is a better way for me to live. My satisfaction comes from choosing good directions and sticking to them.
To set directions for the future, we need to define our starting point, that is, where we are right now. To help us find that starting point, let’s do an experiment.
An experiment
Close your eyes and take a minute to consider the world as it is right now. Then consider the world as it would be if you had never existed. The difference between those two worlds is what I call the global you: not what you own, but what you have done, what you have shared, whom you have loved, whom you have helped. Notice that the global you is made primarily of what you have given away — time, attention, kindness, teaching, caring, and love.
This starting point lets us ask: in which directions do I want to head from here?
Among the several directions we might take from here, let’s consider three: our patients, ourselves, and the people we care about.
Direction one
Your patients
It took me a while to realize that we do not treat cuff tears, or arthritis, or fractures. We treat people who have these conditions. The distinction is important. Knowing how a cuff tear affects the person is much more important than how the cuff looks on the MRI. Two people with similar tears on MRI may be affected quite differently. My untreated and irreparable supraspinatus tear does not limit me in any way. Others with identical tears may be seriously compromised.
It all starts with getting to know the person. When I meet a patient, I shake hands, look them in the eye and ask, “Where are you from?” — I set the stage for two people getting to know each other. Then, before I examine them or look at their images, I ask, “What questions can I answer for you today?” I put the patient in charge of the visit. Contrast that with the surgeon who sits — back to the patient — looking at the x-rays on a monitor and says, “You have arthritis. I can fix that with a joint replacement.”
Then we talk about the whole person — their job, activities, hobbies, expectations, health, and who is at home with them.
After the examination is complete, we discuss the options, non-operative and operative, with the risks and benefits of each. Unless the bone is sticking out through the skin, there is time to consider each of them. They leave informed, in charge, and carrying my personal email so they can ask any questions anytime.
My direction is to grow the global me — that is, I want to do a better job of helping more patients realize their expectations. One of the most helpful tools I’ve found in 55 years of practice is recursive self-improvement. This requires me to track my patients’ outcomes, identifying those who did not do as well as expected, and asking what I could have done differently to lessen the risk of a poor outcome. As a result, I remain in a state of perpetual beta.
When a company representative suggests that I try their latest product, I’m not dazzled by reports from some famous surgeon. Instead, I ask myself, “Will spending money on this new implant or device solve a problem that my patients actually have, or am I just being tempted by this shiny new thing?”
Improvement often comes from simplification — removing what doesn’t matter. A child learns to ride better on an inexpensive balance bike than on an expensive bike with training wheels. A good deal of what we are tempted to add to our practice is like training wheels: more technology, more devices, more tests, more cost, but the results realized by the patient don’t get better. Do we really need a CT scan, an MRI, robots, or virtual reality to provide great treatment to each patient with shoulder arthritis?
Direction two
Yourself
You are the instrument by which everything else gets done. Take care of yourself the way you would a fine car you want to keep running well for fifty-plus years.
Sound body, sound mind, sound finances.
Keep your body fit for duty, not only for the routine, but for when events call for an extraordinary effort. For me that’s an average of at least an hour of aerobic exercise a day, a high-protein diet, plenty of water, fresh veggies, a BMI in the low twenties, no smoking, minimal alcohol, and good sleep habits.
Keep your mind fresh. Read outside your specialty. Argue with colleagues you respect. Write. Walk outside. I photograph birds. I have walked in the cold for hours waiting for a short-eared owl to pose for the shot, and come home with nothing on the camera, but with satisfaction just from being out there in the marsh. I missed the goal, but I was going in a good direction.
Keep your bank account on the safe side, not overextended. Live below your means. The last thing you want is a call from the bank saying that your account is overdrawn.
And be generous and kind to everyone — including the one person you tend to forget: yourself.
We make mistakes. What matters is that we learn from them. For example, I found that trying to reconstruct the “premorbid anatomy” of an arthritic shoulder increased the risk of postoperative stiffness — in spite of vigorous soft tissue releases, the shoulder could not accommodate the new joint volume. As a result I’m now “understuffing” the implants to make sure the patient has great range of motion at the time they leave the operating room.
Direction three
The people you care about
Family, partners, friends, colleagues, teachers, students — the people who matter to us, and the people to whom we matter. Let them share your burdens, and make room for you to share theirs. Let them know you care.
Be sensitive to their needs. Give them help and support before they have to ask for it. When you come home from work, don’t open with “I had a tough day.” Ask, “How was your day?”
We had a family routine. After dinner, each of the kids and I would sit at the dining table with our homework. The rule was that they could interrupt me with any question, anytime. Getting our work done was a family business.
Be bold. When my daughter Susanna ran cross-country at UNC, I would cancel my clinical work, fly 2,350 miles from Seattle to Chapel Hill, watch her run for fifteen minutes, eat hot wings with her at the airport, and fly 2,350 miles back to work — both times I was flying in the right direction.
And of course I’d try to share with my three kids lessons that I’d learned along the way. For example, I’d say that in every situation there are three things to keep in mind: decide what’s important, keep things simple, and don’t fret about the things you can’t control.
Going in three directions at the same time
Your patients, yourself, and the people you care about will collide, because each needs the best of you. Time is not the scarce resource — your good hours are. Most of us give our best hours to work and give the scraps to family and ourselves. Give yourself and the people you care about a good share of your best hours, not your leftover ones.
Your practice will still be there when you’re fifty, after your kids have left for college. But you can never go back and watch their games, concerts, and milestones you missed along the way.
Measure, adjust, repeat
I have been doing this for fifty-five years, in one department, in one city, living in one house. I still wake up every day eager to get to work. That is the result of directions I chose when I was as young, as tired, and as uncertain as you are now. I remain satisfied with these directions; they continue to make me better.
In summary, set your directions and stick to them. Like a good sailor, don’t let unfavorable winds blow you off course.
Follow your patients — contact them at a year and ask, “How are you doing?” Learn from those who are not doing well.
Give a share of your best hours to yourself and to the people you care about.
And once a week, set a special time to ask three questions:
1. How are my patients doing?
2. How am I doing?
3. How are the people I care about doing?
Nobody else can collect this essential data for you. Adjust your directions accordingly.
The same recursive self-improvement that makes us better surgeons can make us better people. Measure, adjust, repeat: that’s the loop.
We began by imagining the world without you in it. You have already made that world better by what you have given.
I hope the global you keeps growing, and that you find deep satisfaction in the directions you choose.
Finally got the shot
Follow on twitter: https://twitter.com/shoulderarth
Follow on facebook: https://www.facebook.com/frederick.matsen
Follow on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rick-matsen-88b1a8133/

