Showing posts with label acromial stress fractures. Show all posts
Showing posts with label acromial stress fractures. Show all posts

Sunday, January 18, 2026

How a surgeon can learn from their own adverse outcomes - an example of intrapractice analysis in reverse shoulder arthroplasty.

From the start of their career, each surgeon is launched on a personal learning curve for each procedure that they perform, progressively refining their approach. The surgeon is the method and this method evolves with experience. The great majority of our surgeries (thankfully) turn out well, thus the opportunity for learning lies in exploring the surgeon's adverse outcomes. One way to accomplish this is to compare a case of, for example, anatomic glenoid component failure to a matched set of aTSAs that did not have this type of failure, searching for surgeon-controlled variables that differed.

Here is an example of this type of intrapractice analysis. Four cases of acromial stress fractures after reverse shoulder arthroplasty (RSA) were each matched to four cases of RSA from the same surgeon's practice by age, sex, diagnosis, implant type, and year in which the surgery was performed. 

Two of the cases were initially non-displaced Levy IIB fractures that went on to displace in spite of immobilization (FX1 and FX2). Two of the cases were Levy I fractures that healed with immobilization (FX3 and FX4).

For each case and for their respective controls, we documented 14 measures of component position that are easily determined on plain anteroposterior radiographs. 

Radius of the glenosphere


Lateralization of the glenosphere center of rotation from the native glenoid bone.


Total thickness of the glenosphere (including baseplate and any augments) measured as the distance from the native glenoid bone to the lateral extent of the glenospherre.


Baseplate inferiorization measured as the distance between the center of the glenoid bone surface to the center of the baseplate. 



Baseplate tilt measured as the angle between the supraspinatus fossa line (white) and the baseplate. Note that values greater than 90 degrees indicate superior tilt in relation to the supraspinatus fossa line.


Humeral distalization measured as the distance between the acromial tip and the superior-lateral tip of the tuberosity. The HD was measured before and after the RSA. The difference (Delta HD) was calculated.



Measured as the distance between the glenoid bone surface and the superior-lateral tip of the tuberosity.


Measured as the distance between the lateral aspect of the glenosphere and the superior-lateral tip of the tuberosity


Measured as the distance between the glenosphere center of rotation and the superior-lateral tip of the tuberosity.

Measured as the distance between the glenosphere center of rotation and the tip of the acromion.
The AC - CT difference and the AC/CT ratios were also determined.

Here is a series of plots of the 14 measurements for the two cases of displaced Levy IIB fractures (FX1 and FX2). In each of the plots, the red dot indicates the fracture case and the green dots indicate the four controls matched for age, sex, diagnosis, implant type, and year in which the surgery was performed. 







Of particular interest in these two cases is the observation that the difference between the COR to acromion distance (AC) and the COR to tuberosity distance (CT) tended to be lower in the fracture cases than for the controls. 


This relationship is not seen for the two Levy I fracture cases that healed witrh immobilization.





Because change in humeral distalization has been implicated as a risk factor for acromial fractures, Delta HD and AC-CT differences were compared among the two displaced Levy IIB fractures (FX1 and FX2), the two healed Levy I fractures (FX3 and FX 4), and their respective controls.


While these data only reflect four fracture cases and their respective controls in this surgeon's practice, they suggest that the AC to CT difference is a more important surgeon-controlled risk factor for displaced Levy IIB fractures than humeral distalization. Thus in patients with patient risk factors for acromial fractures, the surgeon may wish to strive for AC>CT (a greater distance from the center of rotation to the acromion than the distance from the center of rotation to the tuberosity). 

More important than the results for these four cases is this methodolgy by which a surgeon can compare cases for any type of adverse outcome (e.g. glenoid component loosening, instability) to matched intrapractice controls with the goal of identifying potentially important surgeon-modifiable risk factors for future cases. 

Always trying to get better


Sooty Grouse

Mt, Rainier
July 2025



Here are some videos that are of shoulder interest
Shoulder arthritis - what you need to know (see this link).
How to x-ray the shoulder (see this link).
The ream and run procedure (see this link)
The total shoulder arthroplasty (see this link)
The cuff tear arthropathy arthroplasty (see this link).
The reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (see this link).
The smooth and move procedure for irreparable rotator cuff tears (see this link)
Shoulder rehabilitation exercises (see this link). 


Sunday, December 14, 2025

Preventing Scapular Spine Fractures: The Superior Baseplate Screw Question

My friend, Ed McFarland, keeps an ever watchful eye on this blog. He pointed out that in yesterday's post I'd failed to mention another surgeon-controlled variable bearing on risk of scapular spine fractures after reverse total shoulder: the superior baseplate screw. So here's what I think we know about that.

The Clinical and Laboratory Evidence

Increased scapular spine fractures after reverse shoulder arthroplasty with a humeral onlay short stem: an analysis of 485 consecutive cases reported: "we found that 57.1% of the scapular spine fractures (12 of 21) occurred at the distal tip of the superior screw"

Scapular fractures after reverse shoulder arthroplasty: evaluation of risk factors and the reliability of a proposed classification found "Of 16 scapular spine fractures, 14 occurred from a screw tip."

Scapula fractures after reverse total shoulder arthroplasty: classification and treatment: "We no longer recommend placing the most superior screw for metaglene fixation because this appears to lead to a potential stress riser that may contribute to this fracture of the scapular spine"

Scapular spine base fracture with long outside-in superior or posterior screws with reverse shoulder arthroplasty: an in vitro study reported "The main finding of the study was that when the superior metaglene screw (with or without a posterior or anterior screw) enters into the base of the spine with an outside-in configuration, it leads to a fracture at the base of the scapular spine compared to the short screw "not touching the scapula spine" group."



This leads to some interesting questions:

(1) Is it the screw or the hole?


The evidence is that putting a short screw into a too-long hole doesn't reduce the weakening of the bone. The hole is the problem. Leaving the drilled hole incompletely filled may actually worsen the weakening of the scapular spine. Even "appropriate length" screws that don't breach the cortex may still weaken the spine if the drill hole penetrates into the spine base.

(2) Which screw hole is the one to worry about?

We often say "go short on drilling the superior hole". I took a look at the scapular model that lives on my desk. As we see, the spine is not directly superior, but rather posterior-superior.




From this we recognize that the "worry hole" may not be the superior hole (12 o'clock) but rather a posterior-superior hole (10:30 for right shoulder, 1:30 for left shoulder) depending on how the baseplate is rotationally oriented on the prepared glenoid (see diagram of a left shoulder below in which the red trapezoid represents the position of the scapular spine and, for the baseplate orientation in the middle figure, the "worry hole" is at 1:30). 


Of note, with a monoblock baseplate with a central screw, the rotational orientation of the holes is determined by when the central screw is tightened and is often not straight up and down as shown in the left image.

(3) How important are the superior screws?

We took a look at this question in the post "Learning from baseplate failure", noting that most failed baseplates fail by rocking into superior tilt.



This is because the rocking moment is applied to the inferior aspect of the glenosphere.




This rocking moment (red) is resisted by compression of the upper baseplate against the reamed bone (yellow) and resistance to pullout by the central and inferior screws (green).


When this stabilization mechanism fails, the gleosphere rocks up and out. Note that the superior screw is not in a position to resist this rocking.




So how important is the superior screw?

Central Fixation Dominates (60-70% of Total Stability)

The biomechanical literature consistently shows that central fixation quality matters far more than peripheral screw configuration. Studies examining central screw versus central peg fixation demonstrate massive differences in micromotion - on the order of 300-400% - while peripheral screw number shows much smaller effects. 
Central peg fixation was associated with 358% greater micromotion at all peripheral screw positions compared with central screw fixation.  See Central fixation element type and length affect glenoid baseplate micromotion in reverse shoulder arthroplasty, Factors affecting fixation of the glenoid component of a reverse total shoulder prothesis, and Glenoid baseplate screw fixation in reverse shoulder arthroplasty: does locking screw position and orientation matter?

Scapula fractures after reverse total shoulder arthroplasty: classification and treatment."We no longer recommend placing the most superior screw for metaglene fixation."

Peripheral Screw Number: Often Doesn't Matter

Reverse shoulder arthroplasty glenoid fixation: is there a benefit in using four instead of two screws? found no significant variations in micromotion and displacement between 2 screws and 4 screws

Factors contributing to glenoid baseplate micromotion in reverse shoulder arthroplasty: a biomechanical study. found that in homogeneous bone density models, increasing screws from 2 to 4 did not enhance initial baseplate stability

Glenoid baseplate fixation using hybrid configurations of locked and unlocked peripheral screws. found no differences in baseplate micromotion for 1, 2, 3, or 4 peripheral locked screws. Maximum difference between 1-locked and 4-locked screw groups was only 29 µm.

Of course these are lab studies in which the model cannot duplicate the issues surgeons face with glenoid bone of varying quality. 

It is also worth noting that a lateralized glenosphere has a greater rocking moment so may need fixation with more than two screws. See Quantifying the competing relationship between adduction range of motion and baseplate micromotion with lateralization of reverse total shoulder arthroplasty. Furthermore, most biomechanical studies report "micromotion" but don't specify whether they tested rocking/eccentric loading that causes the clinical failure mode we see clinically.


Putting It All Together: A Strategic Approach

The Fixation Hierarchy


Tier 1 - Essential (Contribute Most to Preventing Clinical Failure)
Central screw: 60-70% of total stability; must be long and engage far cortex
Inferior screws: Resist the rocking moment that causes baseplate failure; I go long on these.

Tier 2 - Important (When Safe Trajectories Available)
Anterior screws: Contribute meaningfully to fixation with low fracture risk- usually can safely maximize length of bone hole and screw length.

Tier 3 - Optional/Risk-Benefit Consideration
Superior/posterior-superior screws contribute only 8-12% to total fixation
Positioned near center of rocking loosening, contribute minimally to preventing superior rocking (the dominant failure mode)
Are associated with 40-70% of scapular spine fractures when trajectory enters spine base
I "short" the drill hole in the "worry holes", or in small patients leave them out all together.

Conclusion:


Central fixation dominates - A long central screw engaging far cortex provides 60-70% of baseplate stability.

Inferior screws prevent the failure mode that most commonly occurs - Since baseplates usually fail by rocking superiorly with inferior screw pullout, I maximize inferior screw purchase to directly address the clinical failure mechanism.

Posterior/Superior screws create risk without proportional benefit - They contribute 8-12% to total fixation but minimal resistance to superior tilt, while contributing to 40-70% of spine fractures when drill trajectories penetrate the spine base.

Maximize fixation where it prevents clinical failure (central, inferior), minimize risk where it doesn't (spine-directed trajectories). This requires intraoperative anatomic judgment based on actual baseplate position.

As we noted in our recent post on preventing acromial/scapular spine fractures, this represents another surgeon-controlled variable in a multifactorial problem. Combined with appropriate humeral positioning, CAL preservation when possible, and judicious glenosphere selection, selective screw strategy can help minimize these challenging complications.

It's about holes

Red-Breasted Sapsucker
Washington Park Arboretum
2020

Here are some videos that are of shoulder interest
Shoulder arthritis - what you need to know (see this link).
How to x-ray the shoulder (see this link).
The ream and run procedure (see this link)
The total shoulder arthroplasty (see this link)
The cuff tear arthropathy arthroplasty (see this link).
The reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (see this link).
The smooth and move procedure for irreparable rotator cuff tears (see this link)
Shoulder rehabilitation exercises (see this link).

Sunday, September 14, 2025

Updated: As many as 25,000 acromial / scapular spine fractures may occur per year after reverse total shoulders. What are we doing about it??


Two recent articles Acromial stress fractures and reactions after reverse total shoulder arthroplasty: a case-control study and Risk Factors for Acromial and Scapular Fractures Following Reverse Shoulder Arthroplasty: A Meta-analysis of Over 100,000 Shoulders  confirm that these fractures are among the most common, most serious and most difficult to treat complications of reverse total shoulder arthroplasty. We see that the rate of acromial / spine fractures is not decreasing and that with the increasing use of reverse total shoulder arthroplasty the number of patients experiencing these fractures each year will continue to rise rapidly, perhaps to as many as 25,000 per year globally.



and 7,000 per year in the US.


Although the factors associated with these fractures are well known: osteoporosis, inflammatory arthritis, female sex, older age and lower BMI, corticosteroid use, rotator cuff deficiency, prior shoulder surgery (especially cuff repair), none of these is modifiable by the surgeon.

While some surgeon-controlled risk factors have been identified (screw placement and coracoacromial ligament preservation), other possible factors (humeral and glenoid component distalization and lateralization, acromio-tuberosity contact in abduction, change in acromio-humeral distance, and the timelineness and vigor of post operative rehabilitation) have not been consistently associated with fracture risk.

In that most rTSAs have successful outcomes, by what means can we learn how to reduce the rising number of acromial-spine fractures?

The Shoulder Arthroplasty Failture Research initiative seeks to learn safety lessons - not by statistical analysis of large case series or registry data  - but rather by considering in each individual fracture case what might have been done differently to avoid the patient experiencing the complication = causal modeling.

NASA has had 178 crewed space flights and two fatal flights. The two failures taught valuable safety lessons that could not have been learned from statistical analysis of the 178 "cases".  
In each of two individual fatal accidents, NASA had to model many possible causes of the tragedy. The results of causal modeling are shown below.


Challenger (STS-51L, 1986) Cause: Failure of an O-ring seal in the right solid rocket booster. All seven astronauts died. Cold weather on launch day made the rubber O-rings brittle. Engineers had raised concerns about launching in freezing weather, but management overrode them under schedule pressure. Richard Feynman placed a piece of the O-ring material into a glass of ice water and showed that the rubber lost its elasticity at low temperatures, failing to spring back quickly. Counterfactual: had a cold-tested O-ring been used, the lives of the seven astronauts may have been spared.



Columbia (STS-107, 2003) Cause: A piece of foam insulation from the external tank broke off during launch, striking the left wing's leading edge, damaging its reinforced carbon-carbon panels. The crew module was destroyed on re-entry. All seven astronauts died. NASA had a history of foam shedding from the external tank before Columbia, but it was consistently downplayed. Counterfactual: had NASA addressed the prior foam insulation failures, the lives of the seven astronauts may have been spared.





Consider these two cases of acromial/spine fractures after reverse total shoulder arthroplasty


In the case on the right, most of us would suggest the counterfactual that "if the screw had not been placed in the scapular spine, the fracture would likely have been avoided".

However, in the case on the left, is it likely that the fracture would have been avoided if the surgeon had achieved a lower position of the baseplate, more inferior tilt of the baseplate, more or less humeral distalization, more or less humeral lateralization, by assuring lack of tuberosity-acromion contact, or...? Expert surgeons may have different opinions, but we will only learn by pushing ourselves to answer the causation question, "would the outcome have been different if..?"

So.... 

A. for each acromion/spine fracture case, we should consider

(1) a pre-defined set of causal variables that could have been changed by the surgeon

Screw position: trajectories, lengths, whether any screw is outside-in; distance from superior screw tip to scapular spine; posterior screw proximity to suprascapular notch

Scapular ring status: coracoacromial ligament  (CAL) intact vs transected; any deltotrapezial fascia compromise. 

Construct geometry: humeral distalization, humeral lateralization, neck-shaft angle, humeral inlay/onlay, glenosphere lateralization, glenoid  baseplate tilt, inferior  glenosphereoverhang.  Pre to post op change in acromiohumeral distance (ΔAHD)

Rehab intensity & timing: early deltoid loading milestones.

(2) factors that were non-modifiable for that operation, but critical for counterfactual simulation

Patient bone health: DEXA/T-score proxy; steroid use; rheumatoid/inflammatory arthritis. 

Rotator cuff status: Tear, cuff tear arthropathy

B. Pose explicit counterfactuals
Example queries for each fracture case, for example in a specific case ask: 

  • “If the superior screw had been omitted or shortened (inferior-only fixation), would fracture probability have dropped?” 

  • “If the CAL had been preserved, would modeled spine strain have stayed below fatigue thresholds?” 

  • “If humeral distalization (ΔAHD) had been 3–4 mm less, would the risk have decreased?” 

Pair each patient with 2–4 closest non-fracture rTSA controls (same age/sex/diagnosis/cuff status, bone quality) and run a small within-case causal analysis (not just regression): what single change (if any) most reduces predicted risk for this patient?

C. Convert findings into micro-rules (“guardrails”).
Examples that fall straight out of current evidence:

  • Avoid outside-in or long superior screws when fixation allows; favor inferior-biased screw strategy. 

  • Preserve the CAL unless there’s a compelling reason to release it. 

  • Limit humeral distalization; scrutinize ΔAHD and inferior overhang. 

  • Create a “spine-at-risk” checklist for osteoporotic, inflammatory arthritis, steroid-using, cuff-deficient, very low-BMI patients—flagging surgeon controlled variables that appear most influential on fracture risk in this group of patients..

D. As the library of cases grows: every 10–20 fracture cases, publish short, anonymized notes summarizing the modifiable factors that appearn to have the greatest preventable impact on fracture risk? 


About our two example cases

  • Right-hand image (with a screw traversing the spine): the counterfactual (“no superior screw / shorter screw / inferior-only fixation”) is very plausible given where many fractures localize. 

  • Left-hand image (debate over baseplate height/tilt, lateralization, distalization, tuberosity–acromion contact): literature does not consistently link most of these to fractures, with the notable exception of excess distalization. Capture ΔAHD, CAL status, and screw map; then test those counterfactuals first.

This type of causal modeling is not familiar to most surgeon-scientists, but we should begin learning to put it to use for the good of our future patients.

Our colleague Jon Levy responded to this post:

"Another outstanding post.
Over the past 15 years I have integrated all of these factors into my workflow and planning efforts.
Of the modifiable actions, I strongly believe the greatest reduction in acromion fractures occurred with:
1) inlay humerus — since I philosophically believe in glenoid-based laterization to maximize motion and avoid notching induced osteolysis, implanting the humerus within the metaphysis (rather than above it) had a dramatic reduction in fracture rate
2) preop planning — focus on 3 goals — (a) maximize glenoid fixation; (b) achieve at least 70 degrees of abduction motion before greater to acromion impingement; (c) avoid final position of the humerus being more lateral than preop position.
Preop planning had the greatest impact in year to year variation in my fracture rate."

I asked Jon how he managed the rTSA when the planned reconstruction was too loose. His response was "If after reducing the shoulder, the tension is not right and soft tissue balancing is too loose, I typically will select a +4 semi constrained trial. 

 

With the system I use, constraint is added by going deeper into the poly socket. This essentially equates to a +2.5 but gains additional constraint.

 

I almost never go to a +8"  



Looking for answers





Cooper's Hawk
Matsen Backyard
2021


Follow on twitter/X: https://x.com/RickMatsen
Follow on facebook: https://www.facebook.com/shoulder.arthritis
Follow on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rick-matsen-88b1a8133/

Here are some videos that are of shoulder interest
Shoulder arthritis - what you need to know (see this link).
How to x-ray the shoulder (see this link).
The ream and run procedure (see this link).
The total shoulder arthroplasty (see this link).
The cuff tear arthropathy arthroplasty (see this link).
The reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (see this link).
The smooth and move procedure for irreparable rotator cuff tears (see this link)
Shoulder rehabilitation exercises (see this link).

Saturday, June 28, 2025

The pilot/the surgeon is the method - updated

The outcome of a plane flight can be 

a routine landing (not news)

Or this
recent fatal crash of Air India flight (see news). Update: Air India Probe Puts Early Focus on Pilots’ Actions and Plane’s Fuel Switches. The investigation into last month’s Air India crash is focusing on the actions of the jet’s pilots.

or this


an Airbus A320 flying from LaGuardia struck a flock of Canada geese shortly after takeoff, resulting in total engine failure. Capt. Chesley “Sully” Sullenberger guided the powerless plane into the Hudson River—fully intact—and all 155 people on board survived (see news)

Learning from adverse outcomes requires consideration of the plane and external factors (e.g. geese). But from the moment the plane takes off, the pilot is the method. 

When we do studies of surgical outcomes, we commonly study patient and implant characteristics, as in the very important study Risk Factors of Acromial and Scapular Spine Stress Fractures Differ by Indication: A Study by the ASES Complications of Reverse Shoulder Arthroplasty Multicenter Research Group, a study that sought to determine patient factors associated with cumulative acromial and scapular spine fractures in 4764 reverse total shoulder arthroplasties performed for patients with diagnoses of arthritis, cuff tear arthropathy and massive rotator cuff tears by 24 surgeon members of the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons
Stress fractures were identified in 1 of 50 patients with osteoarthritis and 1 of 20 patients with cuff tear arthropathy or massive rotator cuff tears. In the osteoarthritis group, inflammatory arthritis was associated with an increased risk of fracture. In the cuff tear arthropathy/massive rotator cuff tears group, inflammatory arthritis, female sex, and osteoporosis were associated with increased risk of fracture.

When a plane prepares for takeoff, the pilot is the method. When a surgical procedure begins, the surgeon is the method. In spite of the fact that the surgeon is a major determinant of the outcome, the "surgeon effect" is rarely studied.  

The authors of the study referenced above are in a powerful position to compare outcomes (stress fracture rates, revision rates, patient reported comfort and function) among the 24 surgeons: if indeed there were 4764 cases, the average case volume/surgeon was 200 cases! How variable were the outcomes among surgeons? How much of this variability was due to differences in surgical indication? If surgical indication was an incomplete predictor of the variability among surgeons, what other factors might have been in play? What can we learn from inter-surgeon differences in practice and outcome, i.e. noise?

Hopefully, this study group will consider adding "the surgeon effect" to their research.


After take off, the eagle is the method


Bald Eagle
Leavenworth, WA
April 2025

You can support cutting edge shoulder research that is leading to better care for patients with shoulder problems, click on this link

Follow on twitter/X: https://x.com/RickMatsen
Follow on facebook: https://www.facebook.com/shoulder.arthritis
Follow on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rick-matsen-88b1a8133/

Here are some videos that are of shoulder interest
Shoulder arthritis - what you need to know (see this link).
How to x-ray the shoulder (see this link).
The ream and run procedure (see this link).
The total shoulder arthroplasty (see this link).
The cuff tear arthropathy arthroplasty (see this link).
The reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (see this link).
The smooth and move procedure for irreparable rotator cuff tears (see this link)
Shoulder rehabilitation exercises (see this link).