Showing posts with label reverse total shoulder complications. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reverse total shoulder complications. Show all posts

Saturday, October 31, 2026

Anatomic versus reverse shoulder arthroplasty for patients with cuff-intact arthritis: similar outcomes, different complications


Loose glenoid in aTSA


Baseplate failure in RSA


Dislocation in RSA


Acromial fracture in RSA




Summary

Conventionally, anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty (aTSA) has been used for patients with arthritis and a functioning rotator cuff. The reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (RSA) was developed for shoulders whose rotator cuff had failed. RSA now accounts for about seven of every ten shoulder replacements in the United States. More than half of them are used for patients with cuff-intact arthritic shoulders. 

The question surgeons and patients would like answered is: how do the clinical outcomes of these two procedures compare for shoulders with cuff-intact arthritis?

The short answer: the existing evidence does not show major differences in clinical outcomes between the two procedures. However, the published literature does show differences in the types, seriousness and frequency of complications. These differences are not reflected in revision rates because of the relatively poor outcomes for revision of a failed RSA, which contrasts with the better outcomes for revision of a failed aTSA.

Considering only studies limited to the treatment of cuff-intact arthritis, the evidence suggests: (1) on numeric scores (SANE, ASES, VAS), the two are about the same; (2) on motion and certain specific  tasks, the anatomic often does better; (3) on durability, controlled studies are in the works and the results are as yet unknown.

Numeric scores look alike. Matched comparisons from single practices, a national English registry of more than 7,000 operations, and several pooled reviews all found that shoulder scores after the two operations differed by less than the amount that patients would notice. 

The best results may differ. One study looked only at patients who rated their shoulder 95 or more out of 100. Among patients with osteoarthritis and an intact cuff, 41% of those with an anatomic and 35% of those with a reverse reached that level. Among those who did, patients receiving aTSA could more often lift 10 pounds overhead without difficulty (73% vs 55%) and carry 20 pounds at the side (86% vs 70%). 

Time may change the comparison. The longest comparison came from one surgeon, in shoulders with advanced wear of the socket that were followed for about eight years. The anatomic was better at two years. By eight years the reverse had slightly better scores, more satisfied patients (95% vs 82%) and fewer revisions (2% vs 8%). 

The complications differ, and revision rates do not show it. The complications differ in type: after an aTSA, mainly subscapularis failure early and glenoid loosening and cuff failure later; after an RSA, mainly acromial and scapular spine fractures, instability, and baseplate failure. These complications differ in seriousness: a failed anatomic can usually be successfully converted to a reverse, while a failed reverse is harder to salvage and some of its complications are not revised at all. In a national registry, fewer than one in 20 patients with an unsatisfactory result after an RSA was revised, about half the rate for aTSA. 

Can patients forget their shoulder? A new questionnaire, the Forgotten Joint Score, has now been applied to shoulder replacement, but no one has yet used it to compare aTSA and RSA.

What we know and what we don't. Every comparison of anatomic and reverse so far is observational. Surgeons chose the operation based on their experience, the characteristics of the patient and the characteristics of the shoulder. These factors strongly influence the outcome—perhaps more than which type of arthroplasty is used. 

Much needed randomized clinical trials are underway in the United Kingdom and Switzerland. Until these studies are complete, the relative value to the patient of aTSA and RSA will remain uncertain. 

Now for the details

Clinical Outcomes Are Not Significantly Different Between 

aTSA and RSA for Cuff-Intact Arthritis

The reverse is now the most common shoulder arthroplasty. In a national cohort it rose from about 55% to about 70% of shoulder arthroplasties between 2016 and 2020, while the anatomic fell from about 37% to 27%. Of 95,808 reverses, 53% (51,150) were done for glenohumeral arthritis with an intact cuff (Mayfield et al. [1]).

This post asks what recent clinical studies show about function after an anatomic versus a reverse for the arthritic shoulder with an intact cuff, including whether patients come to forget the shoulder. It also covers what happens when the initial arthroplasty fails.

Only clinical studies of primary osteoarthritis with an intact rotator cuff are considered: studies of patients with outcomes reported by patients or measured on them. Cadaver, finite element and computer models were not included.

Anatomic or reverse for the arthritic shoulder with an intact cuff

In studies of the cuff-intact arthritic shoulder, no difference in patient-reported scores exceeded the minimal clinically important difference (MCID). Where motion differed, it favored the anatomic, but in a matched single-center series the difference was small.

Study

Design (all cuff-intact OA)

What it showed

Leinweber et al., JSES 2026[2]

One surgeon; propensity-matched, 61 pairs; mean follow-up about 2 and 5 years

Over 96% in both groups reached the ASES MCID at both times. Substantial clinical benefit: 95.1% aTSA vs 80.3% rTSA early (P = .027), 91.8% vs 78.7% at midterm (P = .074). Internal and external rotation better early after aTSA, not at midterm.

Baek et al., JSEA 2026 [3]

One center; propensity-matched, 44 pairs, also matched for cuff fatty infiltration; minimum 3 years

No difference in ASES, Constant, SANE, pain, or elevation, external or internal rotation. Same result at age 70 or younger and over 70. Complications 18.2% after rTSA (4 acromial or spine fractures, 3 notching) vs 4.5% after aTSA (P = .089); one revision in each group. Note the difference in the ratio of complications to revisions for each procedure.

Cuff et al., JSES 2023 [4]

One surgeon; B2, B3 or C glenoids; 101 aTSA with high-side reaming vs 93 rTSA; minimum 7 years; not matched

At 2 years the anatomic was better: ASES 85 vs 80, elevation 162° vs 151°. At a mean of about 8 years the reverse was better: ASES 80 vs 77, satisfaction 95% vs 82%, revision 2% vs 8% of the starting cohorts. Note again that revision rate is relatively insensitive to complication rate.

Valsamis et al., BMJ 2024[5]

National Joint Registry for England; propensity-matched, 7,124 procedures, age 60 or older

Fewer reoperations at 12 months after rTSA (absolute difference 0.51%). No clinically important difference in long-term revision-free survival. Similar change in Oxford Shoulder Score at 6 months. 

Shah et al., Bone Jt Open 2026 [6]

Systematic review, 18 studies

Better motion after aTSA. No significant difference in ASES, pain, complications or revision.

Desouza et al., World J Orthop 2026[7]

Meta-analysis of retrospective studies

rTSA scored higher on UCLA, SST and SPADI. None of the differences exceeded the MCID.

Brazilian Society of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery, 2026[8]

Evidence review, patients 70 or older

Very low-quality evidence that rTSA has a lower reoperation rate.

 

Cuff's series is the only one with more than five years of follow-up. The ASES differences were smaller than the MCID, and patients who were revised or lost were omitted from the final outcome comparison. In the Valsamis study, patient-reported outcomes were measured only at six months.

Every one of these comparisons is observational. The surgeon chose the procedure, and the reasons for that choice also affect the outcome. Propensity matching cannot control for variables the surgeon considered but did not record. 

Randomized trials are underway, including RAPSODI-UK [9] and a Swiss trial [10]. 

Until the results are published, the relative value of aTSA and RSA for the patient with cuff-intact arthritis will remain uncertain.

The forgotten shoulder

Numerical scores hide what matters to the active patient: does the replaced shoulder feel and work like a normal one? A shoulder version of the 12-item Forgotten Joint Score (FJS-12) was tested in 60 patients after arthroplasty for osteoarthritis, 49 anatomic and 11 reverse (Feik et al., JSEA 2026 [11]). Mean scores were 64 ± 33 at six months and 70 ± 29 at one year, out of 100. The minimal detectable change was about 14 points. The wide spread shows that many patients are still aware of the shoulder at one year, even when standard scores sit near their ceiling. At present no published study compares a forgotten-joint score between anatomic and reverse arthroplasty.

Near normal

Beleckas et al. (JSES 2025) [12] studied patients who rated their shoulder at least 95 of 100 on the Single Assessment Numeric Evaluation (SANE), at a minimum of two years. In the subgroup treated for osteoarthritis without a cuff tear, 41% of anatomic and 35% of reverse patients reached that level. Among those who did, the anatomic patients had higher ASES (98 vs 95) and SST (12 vs 10) scores. More of them could lift 10 pounds above the shoulder without difficulty (73% vs 55%), lift 8 pounds to shoulder level (86% vs 66%) and carry 20 pounds at the side (86% vs 70%). External rotation was 60° vs 45°. Pain did not differ. The ASES difference was smaller than the MCID; the differences in specific tasks were ones patients noticed. Note that the anatomic patients were younger (median 70 vs 74 years) and followed longer, and the groups were not matched.

Complications Are Different Between 

aTSA and RSA for Cuff-Intact Arthritis

When neither operation has a complication, the outcomes are similar. The procedures differ in how often complications occur, what kind they are, how serious they are, and which of them can be  successfully revised. 

How often. Short-term complication rates are low after both operations, and the direction of the difference varies between series. In a matched comparison of 370 anatomic and 370 reverse arthroplasties for cuff-intact arthritis in patients without previous surgery (mean age 73, mean follow-up 41 months), complications occurred in 4.9% after the anatomic and 2.2% after the reverse (P = .045), and revisions in 3.2% and 1.4% (P = .086; the study had 37% power to detect a difference in revisions) (Friedman et al., JAAOS 2022 [13]; single manufacturer’s registry, several authors with financial ties to the manufacturer). In Baek’s matched series the direction was the opposite: complications in 18.2% after the reverse and 4.5% after the anatomic [3]. A meta-analysis of eight comparative studies in patients 70 or older (1,716 patients, follow-up under five years) found more complications after the anatomic (risk ratio 1.75, 95% CI 1.04–2.96) and more revisions (risk ratio 3.96, 95% CI 1.54–10.15) (Gupta et al., JSES 2026 [14]). In the two included studies that gave reasons, anatomic revisions were mostly for glenoid loosening (9 of 21) and cuff tears (6 of 21); the three reverse revisions were for infection (2) and humeral component dissociation (1). The authors caution that reverses are often chosen for older patients less likely to undergo revision, and that symptomatic reverses managed without surgery are not counted as failures. 

What kind. After an anatomic, the early complication is mainly subscapularis failure; the late ones are glenoid component loosening and secondary cuff failure. After a reverse, the complications are mainly acromial and scapular spine fractures, instability, scapular notching, and baseplate failure [3]. A loose anatomic glenoid can usually be revised to a reverse; an acromial fracture after a reverse is seldom revised at all. For this reason, complications should be reported by type, together with revisions.

Revised or not. A national registry study of 21,918 shoulder arthroplasties with Oxford Shoulder Scores asked how often patients with an unsatisfactory result (mean score below 29 of 48) were revised. Unsatisfactory scores were more common after a reverse than after a total shoulder (27% vs 15%), yet fewer of these patients were revised (4.9% vs 10.6%) (O’Malley et al., PLoS One 2025 [15]). The authors attribute this to a lower threshold for revising an aTSA, which has a reasonable salvage option in conversion to a reverse. The study included all indications rather than only cuff-intact arthritis, and the reverses included shoulders with cuff tear arthropathy and fractures; the results were similar when only elective indications were analyzed. Only about a third of patients had postoperative scores recorded. Even so, it shows directly that the threshold for revising a reverse is higher: a lower revision rate after a reverse does not mean fewer patients doing poorly. The gap between complications and revisions after a reverse is not new: in a systematic review of 782 reverses, mostly for cuff deficiency, complications likely to worsen the final outcome occurred in 24%, but only 10% were revised (Zumstein et al., JSES 2011 [16]).

When. The main late complication for aTSA accumulates slowly. In a meta-analysis of 15 studies of cemented all-polyethylene glenoids, mostly for primary osteoarthritis but including some rheumatoid arthritis, followed for a mean of 11.8 years, radiographic glenoid loosening was present in 41% and cuff deficiency in 44%; 17% had been revised. Implant survival was 93% at 10 years, 85% at 15 years and 82.5% at 20 years (Ranieri et al., Int Orthop 2026 [17]). Revision depends on design, technique and patient selection as well as time. In our consecutive series of 458 anatomics for cuff-intact arthritis with a cemented, pegged all-polyethylene glenoid (mean follow-up 6.7 years), 2.6% were revised: seven in the first two years, four between two and five years and one between five and ten years. Six were for subscapularis failure and only one for glenoid loosening, and Simple Shoulder Test scores did not decline after two years (Schiffman et al., Int Orthop 2026 [18]). 

Most comparisons of anatomic and reverse stop at two to five years, before many of these failures appear. Comparable long-term data for the reverse in cuff-intact arthritis do not yet exist.

When the first operation fails, and what comes after

Patients undergoing revision reverse arthroplasty had significantly worse motion, patient-reported outcomes and satisfaction than patients undergoing primary reverse arthroplasty (Tobin et al., JSES 2026 [19]; single manufacturer's registry). These are different patients, and revision patients start with worse shoulders, so the comparison is observational. In Dr. Frankle's single-surgeon registry of 267 reverses done after a failed anatomic, 10.5% were revised again at a mean of 33 months, most often for baseplate failure. In the 188 with one-year follow-up, the Simple Shoulder Test rose from 2.4 to 6.0 of 12 and the ASES score from 30 to 66 (Narain et al., JSEA 2026 [20]). In a larger series from the same group, 320 first-time revision reverses were done for mechanical failure between 2002 and 2022. Implant survival at 10 years was 82.1% when the failed implant was an anatomic and 59.5% when it was a reverse (P < .001). ASES scores at one year were 64 and 53 (P = .008) (Patel et al., JSES 2026 [21]). The worse result after revising a reverse may make surgeons and patients more reluctant to revise one, so a lower revision rate after a reverse does not by itself mean fewer failures. In one series of 202 reverses, baseplate loosening occurred after 1.2% of primary reverses but after 10% of revision reverses (Bitzer et al., JSES 2018 [22]).

Where this leaves us

The existing evidence does not show major differences in clinical outcomes between the anatomic and the reverse for the patient with cuff-intact arthritis. It does show differences in the types, seriousness and frequency of complications, and these differences are not reflected in revision rates. 

In deciding between the two operations, patients need to know what can go wrong with each, how often, and what can be done if it happens. 


Considering the options.

Sibling pileated woodpeckers

Follow on twitter/X: https://x.com/RickMatsen
Follow on facebook: https://www.facebook.com/shoulder.arthritis
Follow on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rick-matsen-88b1a8133/

References

[1] Mayfield CK, et al. Volume, indications, and number of surgeons performing reverse total shoulder arthroplasty continue to expand: a nationwide cohort analysis from 2016-2020. JSES Int. 2023;7(5):827-834. PubMed

[2] Leinweber KA, Bowler AR, Diestel DR, et al., Jawa A. Reverse and anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty for glenohumeral osteoarthritis: a propensity-matched comparison at early and midterm follow-up. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2026;35(7):1632-1641. PubMed

[3] Baek CH, Lim C, Kim JG, Kim BT, Kim SJ. Comparative outcomes of anatomic and reverse total shoulder arthroplasty for rotator cuff-intact glenohumeral osteoarthritis: a propensity score-matched, age-stratified exploratory analysis. J Shoulder Elb Arthroplast. 2026;10:100050. doi

[4] Cuff DJ, Simon P, Patel JS, Munassi SD. Anatomic shoulder arthroplasty with high side reaming versus reverse shoulder arthroplasty for eccentric glenoid wear patterns with an intact rotator cuff: comparing early versus midterm outcomes with minimum 7 years of follow-up. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2023;32:972-979. doi

[5] Valsamis EM, Prats-Uribe A, Koblbauer I, Cole S, Sayers A, Whitehouse MR, Coward G, Collins GS, Pinedo-Villanueva R, Prieto-Alhambra D, Rees JL. Reverse total shoulder replacement versus anatomical total shoulder replacement for osteoarthritis: population based cohort study using data from the National Joint Registry and Hospital Episode Statistics for England. BMJ. 2024;385:e077939. doi

[6] Shah PP, et al. Anatomical versus reverse total shoulder arthroplasty for primary glenohumeral osteoarthritis with an intact rotator cuff: a systematic review. Bone Jt Open. 2026;7(8):1056-1063. PubMed

[7] Desouza C, et al. Outcomes of reverse vs anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty in glenohumeral osteoarthritis without rotator cuff deficiency: a meta-analysis. World J Orthop. 2026;17(1):110188. PubMed

[8] Fernandes MR, et al. Evidence-based review and recommendations from the Brazilian Society of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery: reverse versus anatomic total arthroplasty in patients aged 70 years or older. Acta Ortop Bras. 2026;34(Spe1):e306296. PubMed

[9] Rodrick HL, et al. RAPSODI-UK randomised controlled trial protocol. BMJ Open. 2025;15(12):e106740. doi

[10] Anatomic versus reverse shoulder arthroplasty for primary glenohumeral osteoarthritis: a randomized prospective study. NCT04629391. ClinicalTrials.gov

[11] Feik ML, Smith AZ, Chen KK, Gehring ZA, Myers NL, Gregory JM. The reliability of the forgotten joint score for shoulder arthroplasty. J Shoulder Elb Arthroplast. 2026;10:100059. PubMed

[12] Beleckas CM, Schodlbauer DF, Mousad AD, Levy JC. Evaluation of new normal after shoulder arthroplasty: comparison of anatomic vs. reverse total shoulder arthroplasty. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2025;34:S43-S49. doi

[13] Friedman RJ, Schoch BS, Eichinger JK, et al. Comparison of reverse and anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty in patients with an intact rotator cuff and no previous surgery. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2022;30(19):941-948. doi

[14] Gupta MS, Krishan A, Rashid A, Lee MH. Reverse versus anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty in patients over 70 with a competent rotator cuff and glenohumeral osteoarthritis: a meta-analysis. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2026;35:1370-1386. doi

[15] O’Malley O, Davies A, Rangan A, Sabharwal S, Reilly P. Is there a difference in thresholds for revision between shoulder arthroplasty types? A National Joint Registry study. PLoS One. 2025;20(8):e0330975. doi

[16] Zumstein MA, Pinedo M, Old J, Boileau P. Problems, complications, reoperations, and revisions in reverse total shoulder arthroplasty: a systematic review. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2011;20:146-157. doi

[17] Ranieri R, Illuminati M, Delle Rose G, Borroni M, Conti M, Fontanarosa A, Castagna A, Garofalo R. Long-term glenoid loosening, radiological and clinical outcomes in cemented all-polyethylene anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Int Orthop. 2026;50(7):1683-1696. doi

[18] Schiffman C, Chin E, Whitson A, Hsu J, Matsen FA III. Anatomic shoulder arthroplasty: a single surgeon’s consecutive series of four hundred and fifty eight patients. Int Orthop. 2026;50:2635-2642. doi

[19] Tobin JG, et al. Revision reverse total shoulder arthroplasty: clinical and radiographic outcomes compared to primary reverse total shoulder arthroplasty. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2026;35(8):1890-1895. PubMed

[20] Narain AS, Larson JH, Hancock JU, Christmas KN, MacFarlane AJ, Nieboer MJ, Frankle MA. Outcomes of revision reverse total shoulder arthroplasty after failed anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty. J Shoulder Elb Arthroplast. 2026;10(4):100060. PubMed

[21] Patel R, Kucharik MP, Schmidt CM 2nd, Kolakowski L, Christmas KN, Simon P, Frankle MA. Revision reverse shoulder arthroplasty after failed shoulder arthroplasty: long-term survivorship and risk factors for failure. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2026;35(10):2346-2353. PubMed

[22] Bitzer A, Rojas J, Patten IS, Joseph J, McFarland EG. Incidence and risk factors for aseptic baseplate loosening of reverse total shoulder arthroplasty. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2018;27:2145-2152. doi

Saturday, December 13, 2025

Preventing Acromial/Scapular Spine Fractures in Reverse Shoulder Arthroplasty: Defining what the surgeon can control.



I'll start out with a few conclusions:

(1) Acromial and scapular spine stress fractures are clinically important complications of reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (RSA), occuring in 3-11% of cases and often resulting in poor functional outcomes such as persistent pain and limited active motion. 

(2) The principal risk factors - female sex, advanced age, poor bone quality, inflammatory arthropathy, cuff deficiency, corticosteroid use, thinned acromion from prior surgery or erosion, proximal humeral migration - are not under the control of the surgeon, except as they affect the decision to proceed with RSA surgery. 

(3) Surgeons do control humeral and glenosphere component selection and positioning. However the evidence guiding practice is not robust due to the lack of standardized nomenclature and what parameters should be measured in future clinical research. 

Here are a set of four easy to make measurements the importance of which is supported by the review below. These address the problem of uncertainty and inconsistency found in published studies regarding RSA geometry. Such measurements will be important in answering the key questions surgeons have: what component positions provide the best function and which minimize the risk of complications such as scapular stress fractures for my patients?

(1) Acromio-humeral distance measured from the acromion to the greater tuberosity along a line parallel to the bony glenoid face (both post-op and pre-op to post-op change).


(2) The perpedicular distance between the glenosphere center of rotation (COR yellow dot) and the glenoid bony face (yellow line)

(3) The perpendicular distance between the lateral extent of the glenosphere and the glenoid bony face (blue line)

(4) The perpendicular distance between the tuberosity and the glenoid bony face (long black line).





Consistent use of these measurements would address much of the current ambiguity in the literature, as illustrated by the following review.

Glenosphere lateralization 

One of the issues in reviewing the literature on "glenosphere lateralization" is a failure of many articles to define the term. Are the authors talking about lateralization of the center of rotation in relation to the glenoid bone (yellow line) or lateralization of the lateral aspect of the glenosphere in relation to the glenoid bone (blue line)? The former affects the deltoid moment arm and the range of impingement-free range of motion, while the latter contributes to the global lateralization of the humeral tuberosity (black line) which affects the soft tissue tension that is important for stabilizing the articulation through concavity compression. As seen in Know Your Glenospheres these two dimensions can be varied independently by changing the diameter of curvature of the glenosphere. The effect of the humerus on the global lateralization is the difference between the black and blue lines. 






Biomechanical studies

Implant positioning in reverse shoulder arthroplasty has an impact on acromial stresses and The effect of load and plane of elevation on acromial stress after reverse shoulder arthroplasty found that glenosphere lateralization, but not humeral lateralization, increased acromial stress.

Factors Influencing Acromial and Scapular Spine Strain after Reverse Total Shoulder Arthroplasty: A Systematic Review of Biomechanical Studies found glenoid lateralization was consistently associated with increased acromial and scapular spine strain. 

In addition, transection of the coracoacromial ligament resulted in significantly increased strains. Although preserving the integrity of the CAL is not an implant-related factor, it is a surgeon-controlled variable. Its importance is demonstrated in two basic science papers: Scapular Ring Preservation: Coracoacromial Ligament Transection Increases Scapular Spine Strains Following Reverse Total Shoulder Arthroplasty and Coracoacromial ligament integrity influences scapular spine strain after reverse shoulder arthroplasty and finally the clinical study Does Preservation of Coracoacromial Ligament Reduce the Acromial Stress Pathology Following Reverse Total Shoulder Arthroplasty? Transection of the coracoacromial ligament consistently increased scapular spine strain in biomechanical studies and was associated with higher clinical fracture rates in the 265-patient study (29.4% vs 13.2% with CAL section vs. preservation).

Clinical evidence

There is a lack of clinical studies that have actually measured the radiographic glenosphere COR lateralization and correlated it with acromial fracture risk.  

Up to 8 mm of glenoid-sided lateralization does not increase the risk of acromial or scapular spine stress fracture following reverse shoulder arthroplasty with a 135° inlay humeral component examined RSA patients categorized based on implant specifications (metallic offset from baseplate and glenosphere selection). The amount of glenoid-sided lateralization varied from 0 to 8 mm in 2-mm increments. The actual glenosphere COR lateralization with respect to the glenoid bone was not measured radiographically. 

Does isolated glenosphere lateralization affect outcomes in reverse shoulder arthroplasty? compared shoulders with the COR 2 mm lateral to the glenoid bone to those with the COR 6 mm lateral to the glenoid bone. Acromion and spine fractures were found it 3% of the 2 mm group and in 1% in the 6 mm group.

Lateralized versus nonlateralized glenospheres in reverse shoulder arthroplasty: a systematic review with meta-analysis found no difference in acromion/ spine fracture rates between RSAs catagorized as "lateralized" and "nonlateralized". Data on the difference in COR to glenoid bone distance for the two groups are not presented.

The risk of postoperative scapular spine fracture following reverse shoulder arthroplasty is increased with an onlay humeral stem did not find a fracture rate difference between lateralized and non-lateralized glenospheres. Data on the difference in COR to glenoid bone distance for the two groups are not presented

Implant-Positioning and Patient Factors Associated with Acromial and Scapular Spine Fractures After Reverse Shoulder Arthroplasty found that "excessive" glenoid-sided and global lateralization were associated with higher fracture rates; "excessive" is not defined. "Total glenoid lateral offset" was defined as the sum of lateralization contributed by the glenosphere, baseplate, and bone graft if present. Data on the relation of the glenosphere COR to the humeral bone are not presented.

Humeral position

The humerus can be moved distally by the glenosphere (inferior positioning on the glenoid bone, inferior tilt, inferior offset) and by the humerus (using an onlay component, high positioning of an inlay component). Humerus distalization can be documented in terms of postoperative position or as the change in preoperative to postoperative position. 

Different methods have been used to characterize humeral distalization making it difficult to compare studies. It seems most intuitive to directly measure acromiohumeral distance: the distance from the lateral acromion to the lateral prominence of the tuberosity along a line parallel to the glenoid face. This approach can be used both before and after RSA.




Up to 8 mm of glenoid-sided lateralization does not increase the risk of acromial or scapular spine stress fracture following reverse shoulder arthroplasty with a 135° inlay humeral component found that the change in acromiohumeral distance (delta AHD) was significantly higher in the stress fracture group. For every 1cm increase in delta AHD, there was a 121% increased risk for fracture. For every 1mm increase in inferior glenosphere overhang, there was a 19% increase in fracture risk.

The risk of postoperative scapular spine fracture following reverse shoulder arthroplasty is increased with an onlay humeral stem found "Increased postoperative distalization is associated with an increased risk of SSF after RSA." While the authors also concluded that  "An onlay stem resulted in a 10 mm increase in distalization compared with an inlay stem, and a 2.5 times increased risk of SSF. " it is apparent that what's important is not only the component design (inlay vs onlay) but also on the amount of distalization, which is influenced by both design and implant position. An onlay component can be inset in the humerus while an inlay component can be placed high with respect to the tuberosity.

Acromial Fractures in Reverse Shoulder Arthroplasty: A Clinical and Radiographic Analysis  greater arm lengthening was more common in the fracture group 

Predictive factors of acromial fractures following reverse total shoulder arthroplasty: a subgroup analysis of 860 shoulders  showed that a significant association of higher postoperative lateralization (by lateralization shoulder angle), lower distalization (by distalization shoulder angle), a lower acromiohumeral distance, and higher age were predictive only for Levy type III fractures. These result are  contradictory to other data, possibly because of small numbers (only 16 Levy III fractures) and the confounder of older age. Notably among the 860 shoulders the fracture types most clearly related to deltoid tension (Levy I and II) showed no association with any measured parameter.

The data on the effect of humeral component lateralization on acromial/spine fractures is inconclusive.

Summary: The current data are incomplete and, in many cases, inconclusive. Humeral distalization beyond 20-25mm appears to increase fracture risk (biomechanical threshold ~25mm; clinical data showing 121% increased risk per 10mm increase in delta acromiohumeral distance). Transection of the coracoacromial ligament consistently increased scapular spine strain in biomechanical studies and was associated with higher clinical fracture rates in the 265-patient study (29.4% vs 13.2% acromial pathology with CAL section vs. preservation).

Basic science data suggest that glenosphere COR lateralization may increase fracture risk, but clinical studies using categorical classifications ('lateralized' vs 'non-lateralized') without actual measurements are inconclusive. 

The effect of humeral lateralization remains unclear. 

Thus for high-risk patients (elderly women, inflammatory arthropathy, prior acromioplasty, thin acromion), limiting the change in acromiohumeral distance (delta AHD) to <20mm,  preserving the CAL, and avoiding excessive glenoid lateralization may be prudent pending better evidence—which will require standardized measurements such as those proposed above.

See also Preventing Scapular Spine Fractures: The Superior Baseplate Screw Question

Fractures


Mt. Rainier National Park

July 2024

Follow on twitter/X: https://x.com/RickMatsen
Follow on facebook: https://www.facebook.com/shoulder.arthritis
Follow on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rick-matsen-88b1a8133/

Here are some videos that are of shoulder interest
Shoulder arthritis - what you need to know (see this link).
How to x-ray the shoulder (see this link).
The ream and run procedure (see this link)
The total shoulder arthroplasty (see this link)
The cuff tear arthropathy arthroplasty (see this link).
The reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (see this link).
The smooth and move procedure for irreparable rotator cuff tears (see this link)
Shoulder rehabilitation exercises (see this link).


Friday, May 30, 2025

How can we prevent acromial and spine fractures after reverse total shoulder?

As emphasized in a recent post, acromial and scapular spine fractures continue to be a major cause of poor results after reverse total shoulder arthroplasty.

A couple of examples to kick things off.

Case 1: A 78 year old man had recognized risk factors for these fractures: osteoporosis and the diagnosis of cuff tear arthropathy. He has been treated for his osteoporosis with Alendronate.

His preoperative and post reverse total shoulder radiographs are shown below.


.


A month after surgery, while his arm was still in a sling immobilizer, he developed pain in his lateral shoulder. Examination revealed a localized spot of exquisite tenderness on the lateral acromion. On an axillary view a non-displaced crack is seen in his acromion at the site of his tenderness.



Case 2: An 82 year old woman had symptomatic cuff tear arthropathy and this AP radiograph


A reverse total shoulder was performed as shown below


Two months after an uneventful recovery, she developed pain on use of the arm and point tenderness over the acromion posteriorly. While plain x-rays were unremarkable, a CT scan documented her stress fracture at the point of her tenderness


While these patients' age, sex, diagnoses of cuff tear arthropathy and osteoporosis were not modifiable, the question is whether there are modifiable risk factors, such as the geometry of the prosthetic RSA reconstruction.

A review of much of the current literature on this topic can be found in this post.

A recent publication, Shoulder Geometry After Reverse Total Shoulder Arthroplasty with a Medialized Glenoid and a Lateralized Humerus Predicts Subacromial Notching and Acromial or Scapular Spine Fractures, attempted to assess (1) whether the difference between the acromion to glenosphere center of rotation distance (DA) and the greater tuberosity to glenosphere center distance (DGT) influences the incidence of subacromial notching (SaN) in shoulders following reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (rTSA) and (2) whether this relationship is associated with the incidence of acromion or scapular spine fractures.



They  conducted a retrospective cohort study of 526 patients who underwent RSA with a medialized glenoid and a lateralized humerus.

After propensity score matching, 360 shoulders were analyzed (240 in the DA ≥ DGT group and 120 in the DA < DGT group). Both groups showed similar improvements in clinical outcomes postoperatively.

The DA ≥ DGT group exhibited a significantly lower incidence of SaN (0%) compared to the DA < DGT group (10.8%, P < 0.001). Additionally, the DA ≥ DGT group had a lower rate of acromion or scapular spine fractures (0.4%) compared to the DA < DGT group (5.0%, P = 0.006) [although a larger sample size will be necessary to achieve statistical power]. 

If we go back to Case 1, the 78 year old man with the acromial fracture, his distance to acromion (green arrow) was ≥ distance to greater tuberosity (yellow arrow).



  1. If we revisit Case 2, the 82 year old lady, her distance to acromion (green arrow) was ≥ the distance to greater tuberosity (yellow arrow).


These cases remind us that age, diagnosis of cuff tear arthropathy and osteoporosis are more strongly associated with the occurrence of acromion/spine fractures than component design or position. That said, patient demographics (female sex, age, rheumatoid arthritis) and shoulder diagnosis (cuff tear arthropathy, massive irreparable cuff tears with pseudoparalysis) are not modifiable, so we need to continue to research modifiable factors that may reduce the rate of these factors especially in high risk patients. 

Possible candidates to be studied are (1) assuring that osteoporosis is under optimal management, (2) minimizing global lateralization of the humerus in RSA, (3) defining the optimal degree of glenosphere tilt and inferior placement, (4) burring down the lateral aspect of the greater tuberosity to make sure that there is no tuberosity/acromial contact when the arm is abducted and rotated, (5) slowing the return to activity after surgery, (6) prophylactic calcitonin, (7) considering a cuff tear arthropathy prosthesis rather than a RSA in high risk patients.

Jon Levy kindly responded to this post stating that his big three for minimizing the acromial / spine fracture risk are 

(1) optimizing glenoid component fixation

(2) avoiding early arc abduction impingement (he currently uses 70 degrees as his goal post).

(3) avoiding lateralizing the final humerus position more than the preop position.

We need to continue explore better methods for preventing these fractures: they are disabling for the patients that sustain them; they are too common. 




Common Yellowthroat
Montlake Fill, April 2020

You can support cutting edge shoulder research that is leading to better care for patients with shoulder problems, click on this link

Follow on twitter/X: https://x.com/RickMatsen
Follow on facebook: https://www.facebook.com/shoulder.arthritis
Follow on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rick-matsen-88b1a8133/

Here are some videos that are of shoulder interest
Shoulder arthritis - what you need to know (see this link).
How to x-ray the shoulder (see this link).
The ream and run procedure (see this link).
The total shoulder arthroplasty (see this link).
The cuff tear arthropathy arthroplasty (see this link).
The reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (see this link).
The smooth and move procedure for irreparable rotator cuff tears (see this link)
Shoulder rehabilitation exercises (see this link).